Fishing is increasingly becoming fun with the sophistication of the tools and accessories used when fishing. One such tool is the fishing reel, and with diehard loyalists standing with their preferred options, the debate of choosing baitcaster vs spinning reel does not seem to end anytime soon. It is true that each of these reels has a separate function, but it is not clear to many anglers how different they are.
Before delving into the crux of the matter, it will only be in order to define some the main types of fishing reels there are on the market. The vast range of options to choose from can make the selection of the right one confusing especially so for novices. However, baitcast and spinning reels are the most popular fishing reels since their unique features make them ideal for virtually all types of fishing, including bass fishing.
Reel Comparison Chart
Baitcast Reels
When it comes to the lure control and accuracy, none of the fishing reels beat the baitcast reels. They are capable of using heavy lines of 10 pounds and even more. One common drawback of the baitcast is backlashing or snarling when the speed at which the spool is spinning outdoes that of the line. This is especially the case when casting into the wind.
The magnetic breaking in the baitcast is used to avert the possibility of backlashes but learning to use the spool tension knob to control the speed of the spool spin can go a long way in preventing backlashes and snarls. This knob is found next to the handles and setting it for a lure should not be as complicated as it may seem. With the rod held perpendicular to your body, loosen the tension on the knob – after disengaging the spool – until the lure begins to drop before tightening it slightly.
When casting, you will disengage the spool and apply pressure on it using your thumb. So, if you want to move the lure forward, you will release the pressure on the spool. This will help you to control the speed of the spool revolution – a skill you want to learn if you plan on using the baitcast fishing reel.
Spinning Reels
The construction of the spinning reels is significantly different from that of the baitcast. They have a stationary skirted-spool onto which the line is wound with a bail rotating around it. These reels can be used with almost any size line but work best with lines testing no more than 10 pounds and lightweight lures. One factor of consideration when looking at casting vs spinning is that the latter is a better performer even in wind casting.
One downside of the spinning reels is their tendency to twist the line, creating knots, tangles and loops. This calls for a replacement of the line, and a trick for preventing line tangles and memory is soaking your spool in water the night before fishing day.
When to Use a Spinning Vs Baitcasting Reel?
As mentioned before, the use of fishing reels casting vs spinning can be used for particular purposes but to decide which one to use for your fishing it is essential to look at what each can and cannot do. Some anglers find the use of baitcast reels efficient and convenient while others think the same of the spinning reels. That usually causes a long argument between the two categories of fishers, and if you are new in the discussion, it is easy to be left hanging.
Strengths and Drawbacks Baitcaster Reels
Baitcaster reels are popular among the experienced fishers, and it is because of what it can do. They sit above the fishing rod allowing for larger spools ideal for heavy lines. This design also makes it possible to have the most extended cast possible. If you are thinking of cracking large fish, then a baitcaster is what you need. It allows for higher retrieval rates with the ability to control casts with much ease. Better yet, your accuracy can increase with the increase in experience.
A lot of practice is required to comfortably operate the baitcast reels because severe backlashes can be a big challenge if you are not used to the reel. These reels are also prone to wind issues, and controlling light lures can be problematic.
Strengths and Drawbacks of Spinning Reels
The open design of the spinning reels and their location beneath the fishing rod give them a lower drag capacity and gear ratios than what you get with baitcasters. Regarding volatility and ease of use, the spinning reels are the better option. They are ideal for light lures and various casting situations. The spinning fishing reels offer more resistance to backlashes and wind and will work well with live baits.
Among the drawbacks of spinning reels include limited distance and the problems of the line memory, twists and tangles. It can be strenuous to control over cast when in flight. Loops on the line might require numerous replacement as well.
Conclusion: Baitcasting Reel Vs Spinning Reel
From the strengths and the weaknesses of each of the two types of fishing reels, it is easy to conclude the option that works best for you. Experienced anglers mostly use Baitcast reels, and if you are willing to learn the techniques of using one, it can be a good option. Spinning reels, on the other hand, are easier to use making them the best choice for beginning and intermediate fishers. In essence, the final decision rests upon you.
